Stay reddy was nowhere near red. Online it looks firetruck red, but it's closer to their pink colorway. If I would've known it was essentially pink, I would've tried sangria instead as I already have a few pink shades. The color is more of a coral based pink, and it's pretty but not what I wanted. The color dots on the website selection section don't match the actual color of the product most times. Just be honest? Besides that the formula as always makes my curls pop, and the other shades I grabbed were refills. Love the formula but be upfront about the colors and include photos of the actual product on skin, hair or something. The bottles themselves aren't enough